Ida C. Hultin| 1640-1677 | Edmund Brown | 1916 | William Wood | |
| 1677-1705 | James Sherman | 1917 | Paulfrey Perkins | |
| 1705-1772 | Israel Loring | 1918-1927 | William Wood | |
| 1772-1816 | Jacob Bigelow | 1928-1929 | J. P. McCarthy | |
| 1814-1815 | Timothy Hilliard | 1928-1929 | F. R. Gale | |
| 1816-1837 | Rufus Hurlburt | 1929-1935 | William Channing Brown | |
| 1842-1843 | Charles Sterns | 1936 | Payson Miller | |
| 1844-1866 | Linus Shaw | 1937-1950 | John M. Foglesong | |
| 1867 | Theodore Dorr | 1950-1951 | Andrew Jensen | |
| 1868-1869 | Henry F. Bond | 1951-1955 | Alexander St. Ivanyi | |
| 1869-1871 | George Knowls | 1956-1957 | James Hammond | |
| 1871-1873 | W. A. Willard | 1957-1967 | Carl Scovel | |
| 1878-1880 | Andrew M. Sherman | 1968-1975 | Michael E. Boardman | |
| 1882-1889 | Nicholas P. Gilman | 1975-1985 | Homer A. Goddard | |
| 1892 | Mr. Russel | 1985-1986 | Wayne Shuttee | |
| 1893-1894 | Mr. Roberts | 1986-1995 | Deborah J. Pope-Lance | |
| 1895-1898 | C. W. Heizer | 1996-1998 | Doris A Hunter | |
| 1899-1900 | Frank R. Gale | 1998-2011 | Katie Lee Crane | |
| 1901 | Alfred W. Birks | 2011-2012 | Gary Kowalski | |
| 1902 | L. Haywood | 2012-2013 | Tracey Robinson-Harris | |
| 1903 | T. C. Beach | 2013-2022 | Marjorie Matty | |
| 1904-1915 | Ida C. Hultin |
2022- | Kathleen Hepler |
Transcribed from posted list outside the sanctuary.
Added Katleen Hepler